Military Drones

MQ-9 Reaper & Modern Military Drones: How UAVs Revolutionized Warfare

Combat UAVs · Unmanned Aerial Vehicles · 21st Century Warfare

The MQ-9 Reaper is the most lethal and capable remotely piloted aircraft in the world, a hunter-killer drone that fundamentally changed how the United States and its allies conduct warfare. Since its introduction in 2007, the Reaper drone has flown hundreds of thousands of combat hours over Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, Libya, and the Horn of Africa, striking high-value targets with devastating precision while its operators sit in ground control stations thousands of miles away.

But the MQ-9 is only the most prominent symbol of a far larger transformation. Military drones — from the Turkish Bayraktar TB2 to Chinese Wing Loong exports to Israeli Heron surveillance platforms — have reshaped the battlefield in ways not seen since the introduction of radar or precision-guided munitions. Drone warfare is no longer a supplement to conventional air power; in conflicts from Nagorno-Karabakh to Ukraine, combat drones have proven to be the decisive weapon system.

MQ-9 Reaper: Overview

The General Atomics MQ-9 Reaper (originally designated Predator B) is a UAV military asset designed for long-endurance, high-altitude surveillance and precision strike missions. Unlike its predecessor, the MQ-1 Predator, the Reaper was purpose-built as a hunter-killer platform rather than a reconnaissance aircraft adapted for combat.

The MQ-9 is operated by the United States Air Force (USAF), the Royal Air Force (RAF), the Italian Air Force, the French Air and Space Force, and several other NATO allies. It forms the backbone of American persistent surveillance and counterterrorism operations worldwide.

Each MQ-9 system consists of the aircraft itself, a ground control station (GCS), a satellite communication suite (SATCOM), and ground support equipment. A standard crew comprises a pilot and a sensor operator, both located in the GCS, often at Creech Air Force Base in Nevada. The pilot controls the aircraft via a Ku-band satellite data link, while the sensor operator manages the multi-spectral targeting system and designates targets for weapons employment.

MQ-9 Reaper — Technical Specifications

Manufacturer General Atomics Aeronautical Systems
First Flight 2 February 2001
Introduced 2007 (USAF)
Length 11 m (36 ft)
Wingspan 20 m (66 ft)
Max Takeoff Weight 4,760 kg (10,494 lb)
Engine Honeywell TPE331-10 turboprop (900 hp)
Max Speed 482 km/h (300 mph)
Cruise Speed 313 km/h (194 mph)
Service Ceiling 15,240 m (50,000 ft)
Endurance 27+ hours
Range 1,852 km (1,151 mi)
Payload Capacity 1,746 kg (3,850 lb)
Hardpoints 7 (2 inboard, 2 mid-wing, 2 outboard, 1 centerline)
Typical Armament AGM-114 Hellfire, GBU-12, GBU-38 JDAM
Unit Cost ~$32 million (per system)

MQ-9 Reaper Armament & Sensors

The Reaper carries a formidable weapons load across seven hardpoints. Its standard ordnance includes:

  • AGM-114 Hellfire — laser-guided air-to-ground missiles, the primary weapon for precision strikes against vehicles, buildings, and personnel. The Reaper can carry up to four Hellfires.
  • GBU-12 Paveway II — 500 lb laser-guided bombs for larger targets and structures.
  • GBU-38 JDAM — 500 lb GPS-guided bombs providing all-weather strike capability.
  • GBU-49 Enhanced Paveway II — dual-mode (laser + GPS) guided bombs.
  • AIM-9X Sidewinder — air-to-air missile (tested, providing limited self-defense capability).

The MQ-9's primary sensor is the Raytheon Multi-Spectral Targeting System (MTS-B), which integrates infrared sensors, a color/monochrome daylight TV camera, a laser designator, and a laser illuminator into a single turret beneath the aircraft's nose. This allows operators to positively identify targets at ranges exceeding 10 km in any weather and lighting conditions. The Reaper can also carry the Lynx synthetic aperture radar (SAR) for wide-area ground surveillance.

MQ-1 Predator: The Drone That Started It All

The story of the MQ-9 Reaper begins with its predecessor, the MQ-1 Predator. Originally designated RQ-1 (the "R" denoting reconnaissance), the Predator was developed by General Atomics in the early 1990s as a medium-altitude, long-endurance (MALE) surveillance platform.

The Predator first saw combat during reconnaissance missions over Bosnia in 1995, providing real-time full-motion video to commanders — a revolutionary capability at the time. After the September 11, 2001 attacks, the CIA and USAF rapidly armed the Predator with AGM-114 Hellfire missiles, transforming it from a pure reconnaissance asset into the world's first operational armed drone.

On November 3, 2002, a CIA-operated Predator struck a vehicle in Yemen carrying Qaed Salim Sinan al-Harethi, a senior al-Qaeda operative. This was the first targeted killing by an armed drone outside a conventional war zone, setting a precedent that would define the next two decades of counterterrorism operations.

However, the MQ-1 had significant limitations. Its 115 hp Rotax engine limited payload to just two Hellfire missiles, its speed topped out at 217 km/h (135 mph), and its service ceiling of 7,620 m (25,000 ft) left it vulnerable to ground fire. General Atomics began developing the Predator B — later designated MQ-9 Reaper — to address these shortcomings with a more powerful turboprop engine, greater payload capacity, higher ceiling, and increased speed.

The USAF officially retired the MQ-1 Predator in March 2018, after more than two decades of continuous combat operations. By that time, the fleet had accumulated over 4 million flight hours.

MQ-9 Reaper in Combat

The MQ-9 Reaper achieved initial operating capability with the USAF's 432nd Wing at Creech Air Force Base in 2007 and was rapidly deployed to Afghanistan and Iraq. Its combination of extreme endurance (27+ hours airborne), precision weapons, and persistent surveillance made it the ideal platform for the counterinsurgency and counterterrorism missions that dominated the post-9/11 era.

Afghanistan (2007–2021)

Reapers became the primary close air support and intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) platform in Afghanistan. Operating at altitudes above most ground-fire threats, MQ-9s provided unblinking overwatch for ground forces and conducted thousands of strikes against Taliban and ISIS-K targets. The drone's ability to loiter over an area for an entire day, passing through multiple crew shifts at the GCS, gave commanders an unprecedented intelligence picture of the battlefield.

Yemen & the Horn of Africa

The CIA and Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) employed MQ-9 Reapers extensively over Yemen and Somalia as part of the campaign against al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) and al-Shabaab. These operations, conducted from bases in Djibouti (Camp Lemonnier) and Saudi Arabia, exemplified the Reaper's ability to project lethal force into austere, denied environments without putting aircrew at risk.

Libya (2011–present)

During Operation Unified Protector in 2011, USAF MQ-9s and USAF MQ-1s conducted strike sorties against Gaddafi regime forces, marking the first large-scale use of armed drones in a NATO-led campaign.

Iraq & Syria (2014–present)

Reapers played a central role in Operation Inherent Resolve against the Islamic State (ISIS). MQ-9s provided persistent surveillance of ISIS positions, struck vehicle-borne improvised explosive devices (VBIEDs), and conducted dynamic targeting of high-value individuals. The combination of Reaper ISR with manned fighter-bombers proved devastatingly effective against ISIS convoy movements.

Bayraktar TB2: The Drone That Changed Everything

If the MQ-9 Reaper established the paradigm of high-end drone warfare for major powers, the Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 democratized it. Produced by Baykar Defence, the TB2 is a medium-altitude, long-endurance tactical UAV that has arguably done more to demonstrate the battlefield impact of combat drones than any other system in the 21st century.

What makes the Bayraktar TB2 remarkable is not its raw specifications — it is slower, smaller, and carries less ordnance than the Reaper — but its combination of affordability, reliability, and proven combat effectiveness. At roughly $5 million per unit (compared to $32 million for an MQ-9 system), the TB2 is accessible to nations that could never afford American or Israeli drones, and its combat record speaks for itself.

Bayraktar TB2 — Technical Specifications

Manufacturer Baykar Defence (Turkey)
First Flight 2014
Length 6.5 m (21 ft 4 in)
Wingspan 12 m (39 ft 4 in)
Max Takeoff Weight 700 kg (1,543 lb)
Engine Rotax 912 (100 hp)
Max Speed 220 km/h (137 mph)
Service Ceiling 8,230 m (27,000 ft)
Endurance 27 hours
Payload Capacity 150 kg (330 lb)
Armament 4 × MAM-L / MAM-C smart munitions
Unit Cost ~$5 million
Operators 30+ countries
Combat Use Libya, Syria, Nagorno-Karabakh, Ukraine, Ethiopia

TB2 Combat Record

Libya (2019–2020): Turkey deployed Bayraktar TB2s to support the Government of National Accord (GNA) against General Haftar's Libyan National Army (LNA). TB2s systematically destroyed Russian-made Pantsir-S1 air defense systems, MiG-29 fighters on the ground, and armored columns, effectively neutralizing Haftar's air superiority and turning the tide of the civil war. The sight of Turkish drones picking off Pantsir systems — which were specifically designed to counter UAVs — sent shockwaves through the defense establishment.

Nagorno-Karabakh (2020): The 44-day war between Azerbaijan and Armenia was the most decisive demonstration of drone warfare to date. Azerbaijan employed TB2s alongside Israeli-made IAI Harop loitering munitions to devastating effect, destroying over 200 Armenian tanks, 90 armored fighting vehicles, 182 artillery pieces, and multiple S-300 air defense batteries. Armenian forces, equipped with Soviet-era equipment and doctrine, had no effective counter. The Bayraktar TB2's thermal imaging footage of precision strikes on Armenian armor became viral propaganda, and the war ended in a decisive Azerbaijani victory. Military analysts worldwide recognized that a relatively inexpensive drone had neutralized armor and air defense systems costing orders of magnitude more.

Ukraine (2022–present): In the early weeks of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Bayraktar TB2s became an international symbol of Ukrainian resistance. Ukrainian TB2s struck Russian convoys, supply lines, and even naval vessels — most notably contributing to the targeting of the Russian patrol boat Raptor near Snake Island. The "Bayraktar" folk song became a viral anthem of Ukrainian defiance. However, as Russia deployed layered air defenses and electronic warfare systems, TB2 losses mounted and the platform's role shifted more toward reconnaissance. The conflict demonstrated both the power and the limitations of medium-altitude drones against a near-peer adversary with integrated air defenses.

Chinese Combat Drones: Wing Loong & CH-Series

China has emerged as the world's largest exporter of armed military drones, filling a market gap created by American export restrictions. Two families dominate: the Chengdu Aircraft Corporation's Wing Loong series and the China Aerospace Science and Technology Corporation's (CASC) CH-series (Caihong, or "Rainbow").

Wing Loong Family

The Wing Loong I is a close analogue to the MQ-1 Predator, with similar performance characteristics. The more capable Wing Loong II, which first flew in 2017, approaches MQ-9 Reaper-class capability at a fraction of the cost, with a 480 kg payload, 32-hour endurance, and compatibility with Chinese precision-guided munitions. Wing Loong IIs have been exported to the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Pakistan, Kazakhstan, and several African nations, and have seen combat use in Libya (operated by the UAE in support of Haftar's forces), Yemen, and elsewhere.

CH-Series

The CH-4 (Rainbow-4) is China's most widely exported armed drone, comparable to the MQ-9 but available to countries that the United States would not sell to. Iraq, Jordan, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Algeria, and several others operate the CH-4. The CH-5 is a larger, heavier variant with greater payload (up to 1,200 kg) and endurance (up to 60 hours), though its combat record is less established.

Chinese drones have been criticized for reliability issues — Jordan reportedly grounded its CH-4 fleet due to technical problems, and Saudi Arabia experienced failures during operations in Yemen. Nonetheless, the sheer volume of Chinese drone exports has made them a major factor in the global proliferation of armed UAV capability.

Israeli Drones: Pioneers of UAV Technology

Israel is arguably the birthplace of modern military drone technology. Israeli companies have been designing and fielding UAVs since the 1970s, and Israel remains one of the world's leading drone exporters. The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) used rudimentary drones as decoys during the 1973 Yom Kippur War to trigger Egyptian SAM launches and reveal their positions.

IAI Heron (Machatz-1)

The IAI Heron is a medium-altitude, long-endurance (MALE) surveillance drone produced by Israel Aerospace Industries. With an endurance of over 45 hours and a service ceiling of 10,670 m (35,000 ft), the Heron is primarily an ISR platform, though armed variants exist. It is operated by Israel, India, Turkey, Brazil, Australia, Canada, Germany, and others. India has been one of the largest Heron customers, deploying the Heron TP (Eitan), an enlarged variant with MALE capabilities approaching those of the MQ-9 Reaper.

Elbit Hermes 450 & Hermes 900

The Hermes 450 is a tactical UAV widely used by the IDF for surveillance and targeting over Gaza and Lebanon. It has been the workhorse of Israeli drone operations for two decades. The Hermes 900 is its successor, with greater endurance (36+ hours), higher payload, and the ability to carry multiple sensor packages simultaneously. The Hermes 900 has been exported to Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, the Philippines, and Switzerland, among others.

IAI Harop & Harpy: Loitering Munitions

Israel is also the world leader in loitering munitions — drones designed to orbit over a target area and then dive into a target, functioning as both a surveillance platform and a guided missile. The IAI Harop carries a 23 kg warhead and can loiter for up to 6 hours. Azerbaijan's devastating use of Harops against Armenian air defense systems during the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war demonstrated the weapon's effectiveness. The IAI Harpy, an earlier anti-radiation variant, homes in on radar emissions.

The Drone Warfare Revolution

The rise of combat drones represents the most significant shift in military aviation since the introduction of stealth technology in the 1980s. UAVs have changed warfare in several fundamental ways:

Risk Elimination

The most obvious advantage of drone warfare is the removal of the pilot from the cockpit. A lost MQ-9 Reaper, while expensive, costs no lives. This has lowered the political threshold for military action, enabling sustained campaigns in places like Yemen, Somalia, and Pakistan's tribal areas that would be politically untenable with manned aircraft losses. Critics argue this makes war too easy; proponents argue it makes war more precise.

Persistent Surveillance

A manned fighter aircraft can loiter over a target for perhaps 2–4 hours before needing to refuel. An MQ-9 Reaper can remain on station for over 24 hours, and with relay crews, coverage can be maintained 24/7 for months. This persistence transforms intelligence gathering from episodic snapshots into continuous monitoring, enabling the "pattern of life" analysis that underpins modern targeting.

Cost Asymmetry

A Bayraktar TB2 costs approximately $5 million. A single Russian Pantsir-S1 air defense system costs roughly $15 million. A T-72 tank costs $1–2 million. When a $5 million drone destroys a $15 million air defense system using a $100,000 smart munition, the economics of attrition favor the drone operator massively. This cost asymmetry has made drone warfare attractive even for nations with modest defense budgets.

Proliferation & Democratization

Armed drone technology is no longer the exclusive domain of the United States and Israel. Turkey, China, Iran, and others now produce and export combat-capable UAVs. Iran's Shahed-136 one-way attack drones, supplied to Russia for use in Ukraine, can be produced for as little as $20,000–$50,000 each — cheap enough to be used as a mass-produced cruise missile alternative. This proliferation has fundamentally altered the balance of power in regional conflicts.

Key Conflicts Where Drones Played Decisive Roles

Conflict Period Key Drones Used Impact
Afghanistan 2001–2021 MQ-1 Predator, MQ-9 Reaper Established drone strike as primary counterterrorism tool; thousands of strikes against Taliban/AQ/ISIS-K
Pakistan (Tribal Areas) 2004–2018 MQ-1, MQ-9 (CIA) Controversial CIA campaign; 400+ strikes killed senior AQ/Taliban leaders but caused civilian casualties
Libya 2011–present MQ-1, MQ-9, Bayraktar TB2, Wing Loong II First NATO drone campaign (2011); TB2s vs. Pantsir-S1 demonstrated drone dominance over SAMs
Yemen 2002–present MQ-9 Reaper, CH-4 First drone strike outside combat zone (2002); ongoing US and Saudi/UAE operations against AQAP and Houthis
Syria/Iraq (vs ISIS) 2014–present MQ-9 Reaper, Bayraktar TB2 Drones provided persistent ISR and precision strike against ISIS; TB2s used by Turkey in northern Syria
Nagorno-Karabakh Sep–Nov 2020 Bayraktar TB2, IAI Harop, Orbiter 1K Decisive: drones destroyed Armenian armor, artillery, and S-300 SAMs; redefined armored warfare
Ethiopia (Tigray) 2020–2022 Bayraktar TB2, Wing Loong II, Mohajer-6 Ethiopian government used drones from Turkey, UAE, and Iran to turn tide against TPLF forces
Ukraine 2022–present Bayraktar TB2, Shahed-136, FPV drones Full-spectrum drone war: TB2 strikes, Iranian one-way attack drones, mass FPV kamikaze drones from both sides

Ukraine: The First Full-Spectrum Drone War

The Russo-Ukrainian war that escalated in February 2022 has become the most important laboratory for drone warfare in history. Every category of military UAV has been employed — from large MALE platforms like the TB2 to tiny commercial quadcopters modified to drop grenades — and the conflict has revealed both the potential and the limitations of current drone technology.

The TB2 Phase (Feb–Apr 2022)

In the war's opening weeks, Ukrainian Bayraktar TB2s struck Russian logistics convoys, fuel trains, and even a landing craft. The footage went viral globally. However, once Russia established layered air defenses and electronic warfare capabilities, TB2 attrition increased sharply and the platform shifted primarily to ISR roles.

The Shahed-136 / One-Way Attack Drone

Russia began using Iranian-designed Shahed-136 (designated "Geran-2" by Russia) one-way attack drones in autumn 2022 to strike Ukrainian energy infrastructure. These delta-wing, jet-engine-powered drones carry a 40 kg warhead and cost a fraction of a cruise missile. Launched in salvos, they saturate air defenses. Ukraine has been forced to expend expensive surface-to-air missiles worth hundreds of thousands of dollars to shoot down drones costing perhaps $20,000–$50,000 each — a crippling cost asymmetry in Russia's favor.

FPV Drone Revolution

Perhaps the most significant development in Ukraine has been the mass adoption of small first-person-view (FPV) drones as precision-guided munitions. Both Ukrainian and Russian forces now produce tens of thousands of FPV drones per month, typically modified commercial racing drones fitted with RPG warheads or other explosive payloads. Costing as little as $400–$500 each, these kamikaze drones are guided by an operator wearing FPV goggles who flies the drone directly into a target — a tank, a trench, a vehicle, or even individual soldiers. FPV drones have made open-ground maneuver extraordinarily dangerous on both sides, contributing to the static, trench-warfare character of the front lines.

Major Military Drones: Comparison

Drone Country Role Endurance Payload Unit Cost
MQ-9 Reaper United States Hunter-killer / ISR 27+ hours 1,746 kg ~$32M (system)
MQ-1 Predator United States ISR / strike (retired) 24 hours 204 kg ~$4.5M
Bayraktar TB2 Turkey Tactical MALE 27 hours 150 kg ~$5M
Wing Loong II China MALE strike / ISR 32 hours 480 kg ~$1–2M
CH-4 China MALE strike / ISR 30+ hours 345 kg ~$4M
IAI Heron TP Israel Strategic ISR / strike 45+ hours 1,000 kg ~$10M
Hermes 900 Israel Tactical MALE / ISR 36 hours 350 kg ~$10M
Bayraktar Akinci Turkey HALE strike / ISR 24 hours 1,350 kg ~$20M
Shahed-136 Iran One-way attack (loitering) ~4 hours / 2,500 km 40 kg warhead ~$20–50K

The Future of Drone Warfare

Military drone technology is advancing rapidly, and several trends are set to transform UAV military operations in the coming decade:

Autonomous Systems & AI

Current military drones are remotely piloted — a human operator makes all targeting and engagement decisions. The next generation will incorporate increasing levels of autonomy. AI-powered systems are already being developed that can identify, classify, and track targets without human input. The U.S. military's Collaborative Combat Aircraft (CCA) program aims to field AI-controlled "loyal wingman" drones that fly alongside manned fighters, handling the most dangerous missions. The ethical and legal implications of autonomous lethal systems remain hotly debated.

Drone Swarms

Rather than fielding individual high-capability drones, military planners are developing swarm tactics where hundreds or thousands of small, inexpensive drones operate as a coordinated unit. A swarm can overwhelm air defenses through sheer numbers, conduct distributed surveillance across vast areas, or saturate a target with simultaneous strikes from multiple directions. The U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) and China's People's Liberation Army (PLA) have both demonstrated swarming technologies involving hundreds of drones operating autonomously.

Counter-Drone Technology

As drones proliferate, so does the need to defeat them. Counter-UAS (C-UAS) systems are one of the fastest-growing sectors in defense technology. Solutions include electronic warfare jammers (disrupting GPS and command links), directed-energy weapons (lasers that can shoot down drones at pennies per shot), kinetic interceptors, and even trained eagles. The U.S. Marine Corps' MADIS (Marine Air Defense Integrated System) and Israel's Iron Beam laser system represent the cutting edge of counter-drone technology.

Stealth Drones

Next-generation combat drones are being designed with low-observable (stealth) characteristics to penetrate advanced air defenses. The U.S. Navy's MQ-25 Stingray aerial refueling drone, while not a strike platform, uses stealth design principles. More significantly, programs like the European nEUROn, the British BAE Taranis, and China's GJ-11 Sharp Sword are developing stealthy unmanned combat air vehicles (UCAVs) capable of penetrating contested airspace.

Naval & Maritime Drones

Unmanned systems are extending from the skies to the seas. Ukraine's improvised naval drones — explosive-laden unmanned surface vessels (USVs) — have struck Russian warships in the Black Sea, including damaging the frigate Admiral Makarov and forcing the Russian Black Sea Fleet to relocate from Sevastopol. Purpose-built maritime drones for mine warfare, anti-submarine warfare, and surface attack are in development across multiple navies.

MQ-9 Reaper Operators

Country Service Quantity Notes
United States USAF, DHS, NASA 300+ Primary operator; largest fleet worldwide
United Kingdom Royal Air Force 10+ Protector RG Mk 1 variant entering service
France French Air and Space Force 12 Armed variant; Block 5 standard
Italy Italian Air Force 6 Used in Libya and Middle East operations
Netherlands Royal Netherlands Air Force 4 MQ-9A Block 5
Spain Spanish Air Force 4 On order
Belgium Belgian Air Component 4 MQ-9B SkyGuardian

Evolution of U.S. Military Drones

  • 1960s–1970s — Ryan Model 147 Lightning Bug reconnaissance drones used over Vietnam and China; over 3,400 missions flown.
  • 1980s — Israel demonstrates effective drone use in Lebanon (Bekaa Valley, 1982); U.S. military takes notice and begins acquiring Israeli designs.
  • 1990s — General Atomics develops Gnat 750 and then RQ-1 Predator; first combat deployment over Bosnia in 1995.
  • 2001 — Predator armed with Hellfire missiles; first armed drone strike in Afghanistan (October 2001).
  • 2001–2007 — Predator B (MQ-9 Reaper) developed and enters service; designed from the ground up as a strike platform.
  • 2007–2020 — MQ-9 Reaper becomes primary USAF combat drone; fleet accumulates millions of flight hours.
  • 2020s — Next-generation programs: MQ-25 Stingray (carrier-based tanker), Collaborative Combat Aircraft (AI wingmen), XQ-58A Valkyrie (attritable strike drone).

The Ethics & Legal Debate

Drone warfare has generated intense ethical and legal debate. Proponents argue that drones enable more precise targeting with fewer civilian casualties than conventional bombing, that they protect military personnel, and that persistent surveillance allows for more careful target identification. Critics counter that the low political cost of drone strikes has enabled extrajudicial killings far from any declared battlefield, that civilian casualty counts have been systematically underreported, and that the psychological toll of constant drone surveillance on populations in places like Pakistan's Waziristan, Yemen, and Somalia constitutes a form of collective punishment.

The legal framework remains contested. The United States has justified drone strikes under the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF) and the principle of national self-defense, but international law scholars have questioned whether strikes in countries where the U.S. is not formally at war constitute violations of sovereignty and the laws of armed conflict. The development of increasingly autonomous systems raises further questions: who is responsible when an AI-controlled drone makes a lethal decision?

"The drone has become the weapon of choice for a new kind of war — one fought in the shadows, without front lines, where the battlefield is everywhere and nowhere."